Bills vs Colts

Head-to-Head Record

All Time
IND
Colts 20 Wins
0 Ties
BUF
Bills 25 Wins

Average Scores

Bills vs Colts (All Time)

Colts 19 PPG
Bills 21.3 PPG

Home Field Advantage

Bills vs Colts (All Time)

Colts at Home 14-8
64% Win Rate
Bills at Home 17-6
74% Win Rate

Highest Scoring Game

Bills vs Colts

72 Total Points
Sep 21, 1997
Colts 35 - 37 Bills

Last Meeting

Bills vs Colts

Nov 10, 2024
Bills 30 - 20 Colts
Bills Won

Rivalry Facts

These teams have played 45 times, first meeting in 1984.

The Bills lead the all-time series 20-25.

The home team has won 69% of games in this matchup.

The last time Colts won at Bills was Nov 21, 2021.

Largest victory: 41 points (Colts on Oct 4, 1987)

Current Form (Last 10)

IND
Colts
4-5 L5
Recent: L L L L W L W W W ← Latest
BUF
Bills
7-3 W7
Recent: W W W W L W L W W L ← Latest

Bills are the hotter team coming into this matchup.

Recent Meetings (Last 5)

Nov 10, 2024
BUF W
Colts 20
@
Bills 30
Nov 21, 2021
IND W
Colts 41
@
Bills 15
Oct 21, 2018
IND W
Colts 37
@
Bills 5
Dec 10, 2017
BUF W
Colts 7
@
Bills 13
Sep 13, 2015
BUF W
Colts 14
@
Bills 27

Upcoming Games for Colts

Dec 28, 2025
vs Jaguars
Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, IN
get tickets
Jan 04, 2026
@ Texans
NRG Stadium, Houston, TX
get tickets
View Colts Team Page

Upcoming Games for Bills

Dec 28, 2025
vs Eagles
Highmark Stadium, Orchard Park, NY
get tickets
Jan 04, 2026
vs Jets
Highmark Stadium, Orchard Park, NY
get tickets
View Bills Team Page

Historical Performance (All-Time Stats)

IND

Colts

All-time performance
ALL-TIME WIN % 72 Seasons
52%
564-510-8
PLAYOFF SEASONS 72 total
29
40% of seasons
CHAMPIONSHIPS Last: 2006
4
1958, 1959, 1970, 2006
RECENT FORM Last 5 years
49%
41-42-1
BUF

Bills

All-time performance
ALL-TIME WIN % 65 Seasons
49%
486-505-8
PLAYOFF SEASONS 65 total
24
37% of seasons
CHAMPIONSHIPS Last: 1965
2
1964, 1965
RECENT FORM Last 5 years
74%
61-22-0

Top Seasons by Wins

All-Time Records
IND
Colts
Top 5 seasons
 Team page →
#1
2005
Lost Divisional Round
14-2-0
87.5%
#2
2009
Lost Super Bowl
14-2-0
87.5%
#3
1968
Lost Super Bowl
13-1-0
92.9%
#4
1999
Lost Divisional Round
13-3-0
81.3%
#5
2007
Lost Divisional Round
13-3-0
81.3%
BUF
Bills
Top 5 seasons
 Team page →
#1
1990
Lost Super Bowl
13-3-0
81.3%
#2
1991
Lost Super Bowl
13-3-0
81.3%
#3
2020
Lost Conference Championship
13-3-0
81.3%
#4
2022
Lost Divisional Round
13-3-0
81.3%
#5
2024
Lost Conference Championship
13-4-0
76.5%

Related Matchups

Other Colts Matchups
IND
Colts
vs
CIN
Bengals
View Matchup
Other Colts Matchups
IND
Colts
vs
PHI
Eagles
View Matchup
Other Colts Matchups
IND
Colts
vs
CAR
Panthers
View Matchup